| PANCH CHULI GROUP OF PEAKS |
| |
The most visible symbol in the Munsyari
valley are the peaks of Panch Chuli, named after the five
Pandava brothers from the Indian epic Mahabharata. The peaks
represent their cooking hearths (chulis) where they cooked
their last meal before ascending to heaven. From the Wayfarer
Mountain Resort at sunrise, you can get to watch a spectacular
sunrise. In the evening, a little after sunset, at times you
can be witness to a magnificent moon rise as well. |
| |
The Panch Chuli peaks lie in Eastern
Kumaun and form the watershed between the Gori and the Darma
Ganga valleys. The eastern approaches are through Sona and
Meola Glaciers. The Uttari and Dakshini Balati glaciers guard
the western approaches. The peaks are numbered NW to SE, I
(6355m/20851ft), II (6904m/22652ft) , III (6312m/2071 Oft),
IV (6334m/20782ft) and V (6437m/21120ft). Naming the peaks
from west to east breaks with the tradition of giving the
highest peak the lowest number, but the nomenclature has become
too well established to be changed now. |
| |
| Early Expeditions from the East |
| |
The mountaineering history of these peaks
began with the British mountaineer Hugh Ruttledge (1929).
He saw the group at close quarters from high up on the Sona
Glacier. He examined the routes and thought that the north
arete (sharp ridge) might be possible. After 21 years two
teams examined the eastern approaches. WH Murray (1950) and
his Scottish team followed the Ruttledge route. They intended
to reach the north col and follow the northeast ridge; however,
they found the terrain too difficult. Just 20 days later came
Kenneth Snelson (British) and J de V Graaff (South African).
They reached the upper Sona Glacier by early September and
found that its head was a cradle of 182m (600 ft) cliffs blocking
the route to the northeast summit's ridge. |
| |
They considered the south ridge, but
wrote: 'The ridge towards south col has a rather easier gradient
but it is very broken, and heavily corniced.' They too abandoned
their attempt on the south-east face after 122m (400ft). |
| |
| After these attempts, the eastern approaches were left alone.
Two more teams in 1970 and 1988 also tried them unsuccessfully. |
| |
| Attempts from the West |
| |
The western approaches were tried one
year after Murray. In 1951 Heinrich Harrer and Frank Thomas
(Austrians) were joined by two Sherpas and a botanist. Though
their account in the Himalayan Journal is not very explicit,
their photographs in the archives clearly indicate that they
pioneered the route through the Uttari Balati Glacier, bypassing
three ice-falls. Together with the Sherpas, Harrer reached
the Balati plateau and examined the north and west ridges.
They tried the west ridge but a Sherpa fell off on hard blue
ice. Harrer gave up. They spent only 16 days on the mountains
but during that time they pioneered the route which was followed
by all subsequent expeditions from this side. |
| |
| Wrong claims |
| |
In 1952, the Indian climber PN Nikore
followed the Harrer route and his attempt in June almost coincided
with an attempt by another team led by DO Joshi which included
Major John Dias. Both teams reached the Balati Plateau. Nikore
returned in 1953 and claimed a solo ascent of the peak. Without
any convincing proof, he was disbelieved and the claim ignored. |
| |
Group Captain AK Chowdhury led a team
sponsored by the Indian Mountaineering Foundation to this
group in 1964. Following the Uttari Balati Glacier, they reached
the Balati Plateau. Their cursory attempt on peak II failed.
They then claimed ascents of Peaks III, IV and V in two days
(and two peaks on the same day). |
| |
These peaks stand above the southern
valley of Pyunshani and are completely unapproachable from
the Balati Plateau. To climb these peaks, as claimed, the
party would have had to climb over very difficult terrain
covering almost 10km (6 miles) in one day, above 6300m (20670ft)
crossing low cols. The party had mistakenly climbed three
distinct humps situated near their camps and running east-west
from peak II instead of peaks III, IV and V, which broadly
run north-south. The records were corrected after 28 years,
when the mistake was pointed out by the 1992 Indian-British
expedition. |
| |
| First Ascents |
| |
The history of the Panch Chuli group
continued with two large expeditions from the Indo-Tibet Border
Police. The first team in 1972 was led by Hukam Singh. They
powered their way to the Balati Plateau via the Harrer route
and made the first-ever ascent of peak I. Repeating their
route, Mahendra Singh led another team in 1973. The entire
route on the southwest ridge was fixed with almost 3000m (9843ft)
of rope. On 26th May 1973, 18 people climbed the summit of
Panch Chuli II, the highest peak of the group. |
| |
The mountain was then left alone for
some 18 years. In 1991 two routes were climbed via the eastern
approaches by teams from the Indian Army. The first team followed
the Sona Glacier, climbed the northeast slopes to reach above
the north col and established a camp on the north ridge. The
ridge was followed to the top, and thus the route suggested
by Ruttledge in 1929 was finally completed after 61 years.
The second army team followed Murray's route to the upper
Meola Glacier. They pitched a high camp following the southeast
slopes to the east ridge. The summit team broke the cornice
to reach the top, and thus the route suggested by Snelson-Graaff
was also completed, after 41 years. |
| |
| Last Climbs |
| |
The scene finally shifted back to the
west. The Indian-British expedition 1992 (jointly led by Sir
Chris Bonington and Harish Kapadia) followed the route along
the Uttari Balati Glacier to the Balati Plateau. On the way
the team divided into groups to climb Sahadev East (5757m/18889ft),
Menaka (6000m/19686ft) and Rajrambha (6537m/21448ft). On peak
II, a team of three climbed the southwest ridge. It was a
hard climb on ice, keeping well away from the hanging cornices.
Compared to the earlier ascent, only 60m (197ft) of rope was
fixed on the ridge. This was only the second ascent of the
southwest ridge, made after 19 years. |
| |
Another team of two pioneered a new route
up the steep and icy west ridge, with bivouacs. They descended
the southwest ridge completing the traverse. Thus the route
tried by Harrer was completed after 41 years. |
| |
The 1992 expedition later made the first
ascent of peak V. On this peak Stephen Venables, a leading
English mountaineer, fell while returning from the peak. He
survived despite serious injuries and was airlifted in a daring
helicopter rescue from the high camp. Peak IV was climbed
in 1995 by a team from New Zealand. Peak III still remains
unscaled, though it was attempted by two expeditions from
Bombay in 1996 and 1998, both of which resulted in accidents. |
| |